Jack Franklin

Hiding implementation details with React hooks

It's fair to say that the introduction of hooks in React 16.8 has really changed how we build React components. They certainly take some getting used to, but once the concept clicks in your head it becomes clear that they are a superior mechanism for building complex components when compared to the old lifecycle methods.

One area where hooks shines is in reusing code across components. Those of you who have been doing React for a long time will remember mixins (if you don't it's not a problem as they are now removed from React!), which attempted to solve sharing functionality across two components. After that people tackled the problem of code-reuse with Higher-Order Components and also Render Props, but those came with their own problems. I think that hooks are the best solution yet.

Both Higher-Order Components and Render Props still have their place and use cases and they are still good patterns to have in your toolbox.

Custom hooks can use hooks

The real moment for me was realising two things:

Suddenly, code reuse with hooks becomes as simple as writing functions. We've all been doing this since we started programming; spotting some code that's duplicated and wrapping it in a function. Custom hooks are just functions with a convention that they start with the word use:

const useCounter = () => {
const [count, setCount] = useState(0)

useEffect(() => {
const id = setTimeout(() => {
setCount(c => c + 1)
}, 500)

return () => clearTimeout(id)

return count

You can see this running on CodeSandbox.

Compare this to how you'd write a "regular" JS function:

const counter = () => {
let count = 0

setTimeout(() => {
count = count + 1
}, 500)

return count

You can see that whilst the hook version contains some React specifics (namely the useState and useEffect calls), the logic is largely the same.

The benefits of hidden implementation details

Until now in this post I've focused purely on the reuse benefits that hooks provide. Continuing with the above example, now any component in our system can easily use the useCounter hook and if we want to update that logic we can do it in just one place. You can imagine this being a hook that provides logic for user authentication, for example, rather than a slightly contrived blog post demo.

There is another benefit to hooks (which also applies to JS functions): hidden implementation details. The reason I think this is such a big benefit is because when you're working on a codebase, you likely have a million things in your head that you're thinking about. Say you're working on a component that happens to use the useCounter hook, amongst other things, and this component was written by your colleague. This is the first time you've worked with this component so you're skimming the code to build up a picture in your head of what it does. The beauty of seeing the useCounter hook is that you do not have to care or worry about how it works. You can tell from seeing this line:

const count = useCounter()

That it's going to give you a count, and from seeing it in the browser you'll know that it increments. Compare that one line to the 10 lines above that implement the useCounter hook. Reading the line that calls the hook is 10% of the lines of code that the full hook implementation is, so you've just saved yourself a bunch of space in your brain for something more important (and this gap gets bigger with larger hooks).

The beauty of hooks is that they let you lean on functionality without caring about how it works. Higher-Order Components and Render Props do this too, but they introduce more ceremony and work to do it. Hooks are just function calls.

When to extract a custom hook

As always in programming, the rules aren't clearcut. My advice for creating custom hooks would be to feel the pain first: until you have logic that's exactly the same in at least two components, don't create a hook. Pre-emptively creating one and trying to predict how you're going to use it is probably going to leave you with an overcomplicated hook that doesn't do an elegant job of solving your problems.